extradition averted - Turkish authorities could not answer the Court's questions

Higher Regional Court Cologne, Court's Orders of 01.02.2017 and 08.08.2016 – 6 AuslA 70/16 – 58 - cancellation of a German extradition arrest-warrant based on an extradition-request from Turkey 

Extradition lawyer Dr. Martin Rademacher successfully averted the detention and extradition of a Turkish national. The human rights situation in Turkey is unacceptable and in extradition proceedings we are glad to watch, that German courts are aware of the facts.

Turkey had requested extradition for the execution of a criminal sentence against our client. Two years ago the 72-year-old man of Turkish nationality had been sentenced to a prison sentence of seven and a half years in Turkey for the alleged attempted murder during a private dispute. Despite the international arrest warrant from Turkey the Higher Regional Court in Cologne released our client relatively early from custody but fixed a high bail as a security.

However, there is, as yet, no uniform directive of the judiciary not to acknowledge Turkish arrest warrants at all. It is obvious, nevertheless, that the treatment of individual cases apparently follows a certain pattern. Based on this pattern, the Higher Regional Court in Cologne (ruling from 08.08.2016 - 6 AuslA 70/16 - 58) stated already in August last year that at our request the provisional extradition custody order had been lifted.

In the further course of the proceedings Turkey was asked to provide a detailed statement on its human rights situation, in particular with regard to the conditions of detention in Turkey. After the request was not responded to by the Turkish judiciary, the Court in Cologne set a final deadline for their response. Even after the German Foreign Office had been involved, there was only a blanket reply from Turkey, which simply claimed that the procedure there corresponds to the internationally accepted standards of human rights.

Since the Turkish authorities had sought to avoid answering the Court's questions, the Cologne Higher Regional Court rejected the extradition with the appropriate justification that Turkey has not provided reliable assurances. Is to be added, that it normally is a delicate exercise to judge, whether such assurances can be accepted as relevant facts for the assessment of a risk. Nevertheless the Turkish assurances were clearly insufficient.

Please call us on +49 (0) 211 1718380 or email us at duesseldorf@ra-anwalt.de to find out how we can help you.

Our firm maintains a 24 Hour Emergency Line +49(0)172-2112373 or +49(0)172-7056055

Contact us ...