1. Introduction

The extradition process is part of international mutual legal assistance in criminal matters. It is not a standalone criminal proceeding in which the person’s guilt is determined, but rather a formal procedure designed to support criminal prosecution in another country. But we mustn’t misunderstand this either: the extradition process is not merely a procedural mechanism for transferring suspects across borders. Human rights protections are an important part of extradition proceedings. And not least for this reason, the formal requirements for an extradition request from German courts are taken so seriously that extraditions repeatedly fail because the requesting states are unable to meet them.

Extradition proceedings are not an everyday occurrence. Anyone facing extradition proceedings based on an international arrest warrant needs a highly specialized lawyer in Germany who knows the extradition process inside and out.

In Germany, the proceedings regarding an extradition request are primarily governed by the “Act on International Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters” (IRG - „Gesetz über die internationale Rechtshilfe in Strafsachen"). Furthermore, one must be familiar with the extradition treaties, such as the European Convention on Extradition, which has 51 signatory states, including states that are only partially situated in Europe or lie outside Europe – such as, on the one hand, Turkey and the Russian Federation, and on the other, Israel, South Africa, Chile and the Republic of Korea (South Korea), to name but a few examples. Another example is the extradition treaty between the Federal Republic of Germany and the USA, which was supplemented by additional agreements dating from 1986 and 2006, and the extradition agreement between the European Union and the USA, to which Germany is also bound.

In extradition proceedings, the guilt of the person sought for extradition is not examined at all—with very limited exceptions. Such an examination of the suspicion of a crime is only considered if special circumstances of the case give rise to the need to examine whether the persons sought for extradition truly appear sufficiently suspected of the offense with which they are charged (see Section 10(2) IRG). However, if the person sought asserts that they are being wrongfully prosecuted, the court must address this claim. Whether the person subject to prosecution’s claims should be investigated through an examination of the grounds for suspicion depends on whether concrete evidence justifies such an examination.

Otherwise, in Germany, the sole decision is whether the person subject to persecution will be extradited based on a received extradition request and whether they will be held in extradition custody in Germany pending a decision on the matter. However, no standalone criminal trial takes place.

The German “Law on International Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters” (IRG) retained the traditional terminology even with the introduction of the European Arrest Warrant, although the underlying European “Framework Decision” (RbEuHb) marks a conceptual shift and refers not to “extradition” but solely to a simplified system of “surrender of persons.”

Since the enactment of the European Arrest Warrant Act (EuHbG) in 2004, the IRG has thus effectively regulated two distinct extradition procedures in Germany: namely, the traditional extradition procedure based on international arrest warrants—in which extradition treaties and international agreements also play a major role (Section 1(3) IRG) —and the partially simplified extradition procedure for EU member states based on the European Arrest Warrant. In both types of extradition proceedings, the requesting states cannot compel Germany to immediately place a person subject to prosecution in extradition custody here and ultimately even to extradite them. Both decisions are subject to a lengthy process in Germany—namely, both the decision regarding domestic extradition detention pending extradition and the decision on the admissibility of extradition. These processes take months, and no one need fear being transferred to another country immediately after being arrested in Germany. However, the common practice in Germany is that arrested persons are held in extradition detention here for the duration of the extradition proceedings.

However, even after the introduction of the European Arrest Warrant in 2004, European states cannot issue binding orders to member states to take a person into custody in Germany.

Despite its name, the European Arrest Warrant is not actually an arrest warrant that European member states can use to compel an arrest; rather, it is a request for extradition, on the basis of which  detention pending extradition can be ordered in Germany if the conditions are met and the European Arrest Warrant is sufficient in terms of both form and content in the specific case. I have certainly seen cases in which the European Arrest Warrant was not sufficient to place someone in detention here in Germany. But it must, of course, be noted that the European Arrest Warrant often does lead to  detention, particularly in the case of foreigners without strong social ties in Germany.

In addition to the central “Law on International Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters” (IRG), the “Guidelines for Dealings with Foreign Countries in Criminal Matters” (RiVASt) specify and supplement the IRG in Germany. These guidelines read like laws and are binding on public prosecutors’ offices and other authorities, as well as, to a large extent, on courts (see No. 3, para. 1, RiVASt). In practice, these guidelines are regarded as a valuable guide for the conduct of proceedings.

Furthermore, there is now an extensive body of case law from the German Federal Constitutional Court, the European Court of Justice (ECJ), and the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) regarding extradition proceedings, which has continuously raised the standards for judicial decisions on pretrial detention pending extradition and on the admissibility of extradition.

In Germany, the domestic extradition procedure is divided into a judicial “admissibility proceeding” before one of the 24 Higher Regional Courts (OLG) in Germany, in which the legality of the extradition is reviewed by the OLG with local jurisdiction, and into an administrative “authorization proceeding,” in which a Ministry of Justice—or, in the case of the European Court of Justice (EuHB), a Public Prosecutor’s Office—as the authorizing authority re-examines the legality of the extradition, but also assesses its appropriateness in terms of foreign policy and criminal policy.

In practice, the “admissibility proceedings” before the Higher Regional Courts are of far greater importance to the person being sought, because this is the only venue where they can raise objections to the extradition. It is also rare for an extradition deemed admissible by the Higher Regional Court to subsequently be denied in the governmental “authorization proceedings.” I have seen this happen in only a few cases so far.

2. Jurisdiction, procedural principles

In Germany, jurisdiction over extradition proceedings and the question of detention lies with the Public Prosecutor’s Office at the Higher Regional Court (= Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor (GenStA)) and the Higher Regional Court (OLG) in whose district the person sought is arrested for the purpose of extradition or, if no arrest is made by the police, is first investigated (Section 14(1) of the International Extradition Act (IRG)).

If several persons subject to extradition are arrested or investigated for involvement in the same offence in different jurisdictions of different Higher Regional Courts for the purpose of extradition, jurisdiction is determined by which Higher Regional Court or which GenStA was first seized of the matter (Section 14(2) IRG). If the whereabouts of the person sought are unknown, the Federal Court of Justice shall determine the competent Higher Regional Court (Section 14(3) IRG).

Section 14 IRG is an exclusive special provision; once the territorial jurisdiction of the Higher Regional Court has been established, it remains in force until the conclusion of the extradition proceedings.

Decisions of the Higher Regional Courts are, in principle, not subject to appeal (Section 13(1), second sentence, of the IRG), but the Higher Regional Court may change its decisions if new facts come to light (Sections 33 of the IRG).

The Federal Court of Justice rules on individual points of law only upon referral by a Higher Regional Court in preliminary ruling proceedings (Section 42 of the IRG).

The person sought may only lodge a constitutional complaint with the Federal Constitutional Court against a decision by the Higher Regional Court ordering detention pending extradition or definitively declaring the extradition admissible; however, proceedings under Section 33 of the IRG and, where applicable, a subsequent hearing in accordance with Sections 33a of the StPO and 77 of the IRG must first be conducted, if necessary.

3. Application of criminal procedure principles in extradition proceedings

Extradition proceedings in Germany before the Higher Regional Court also incorporate rules from the Code of Criminal Procedure. Principles and safeguards of criminal procedure apply, and Section 77 of the Extradition Act (IRG) refers to the provisions of the Judiciary Organisation Act (GVG) and its Introductory Act (EGVG), the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO), the Youth Courts Act (JGG) and the Act on Administrative Offences (OWIG).
The judicial extradition proceedings before the Higher Regional Court guarantee the person subject to extradition the essential guarantees of criminal procedure. They must be heard (cf. Article 103(1) of the Basic Law) and have the right to remain silent. The person sought may engage a defence counsel at any stage of the proceedings (Section 40(1) of the International Extradition Act (IRG)) and, if they do not have a defence counsel of their own choosing, a court-appointed defence counsel must be assigned to them (Section 40(2) IRG), who is paid from the public purse.

Above all, in Germany, measures involving deprivation of liberty in extradition proceedings are subject to judge's prerogative (see Article 104(1), (2) of the Basic Law), and in the case of pre-extradition detention, the constitutional requirement to expedite the proceedings as rapidly as possible applies.

4. Authorization proceeding - the final review

As said in the introduction, in Germany, the domestic extradition procedure is divided into a judicial “admissibility proceeding” before one of the 24 Higher Regional Courts (OLG) and into an administrative “,” in which a Ministry of Justice - or, in the case of the European Court of Justice (EuHB), a Public Prosecutor’s Office — as the authorizing authority re-examines the legality of the extradition, but also assesses its appropriateness in terms of foreign policy and criminal policy.

The final review of the authorisation for extradition takes place in an administrative procedure once the Higher Regional Court has declared the extradition admissible in judicial proceedings. In this respect, there are two strictly separate phases of the extradition procedure.

In the second phase – the authorisation procedure – the lawfulness of the extradition is reviewed once again, as well as its appropriateness in terms of foreign and criminal policy. Such inter-state issues and the discretion of the authorising authority are not the subject of the judicial admissibility proceedings, but rather of the authorisation procedure.

In Germany, the original responsibility for the authorisation procedure lies with the Federal Ministry of Justice, with the Federal Office of Justice (BfJ) being called upon on behalf of the Federal Ministry. Where extradition proceedings within the EU on the basis of the European Arrest Warrant are concerned, the public prosecutors’ offices act as the competent authorising authorities.

Given the two strictly separate phases – the admissibility proceedings (court) and the authorisation proceedings (authority/executive) – the authorisation proceedings do not even take place if the Higher Regional Court (OLG) declares the extradition to be inadmissible; in that case, the authorising authority may no longer approve the extradition.

 

 

5. Course of extradition proceedings

The course of extradition proceedings is characterized by the fact that the Higher Regional Court (OLG) decides on the admissibility of extradition (Section 29 IRG) and on the ordering and continuation of extradition detention (Sections 15, 16 IRG). There is no second instance. Following the Higher Regional Court’s decision, the only remaining option is to appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court (see below).

In Germany, with very rare exceptions, there are no court hearings before the Higher Regional Court at which the Higher Regional Court sees the person subject to extradition in person. If the person subject to extradition is to be heard in person during the extradition proceedings, the hearing takes place in the Local Court, which merely conducts the hearing and then forwards the transcript of the hearing to the Higher Regional Court, but has no decision-making authority itself. Although the Higher Regional Court (OLG) is legally authorized under Section 30(2), first sentence, of the International Extradition Act (IRG) to personally question the person subject to extradition, I have only ever witnessed this once—when the person I was representing was herself a very prominent lawyer. Otherwise, it almost never happens.

Furthermore, the course of the proceedings is characterized by the fact that the State Attorney General’s Office (GenStA) files motions with the Higher Regional Court (OLG) regarding extradition detention and the admissibility of extradition, on which the person subject to extradition must be heard before the OLG renders a decision.

During the ongoing extradition proceedings, the GenStA may also decide independently at any time on the continuation of pretrial detention pending extradition. According to Section 24(2) of the International Extradition Act (IRG), the pretrial detention order must always be revoked if the GenStA files a motion to that effect with the OLG and orders the release of the person sought. In general, the Office of the Attorney General plays a central role in German extradition proceedings, as the Higher Regional Court (OLG) can only rule on the admissibility of extradition once the Office of the Attorney General has filed a motion to that effect.

There are no strict time limits on the duration of extradition proceedings in Germany. If the person sought does not consent to extradition, extradition proceedings will in any case last several months. And if the person sought is no longer in extradition custody, the proceedings can drag on for much longer, because they are no longer bound by the requirement for expedited proceedings as in cases involving detention.

 

6. Search via SIS or INTERPOL

Extradition proceedings typically begin with an international search for the “fugitive” in the SIS (Schengen Information System) or through INTERPOL, unless a state specifically requests the arrest and extradition of a person whose whereabouts are known. Any country may address the extradition request directly to the country where the person sought for criminal prosecution or enforcement of a sentence is believed to be located.

However, the vast majority of cases in Germany are handled through the SIS (Schengen Information System) or via INTERPOL. The public prosecutor’s office and police officers are then authorized to make a provisional arrest if the legal requirements for an extradition arrest warrant are met (Section 19 IRG).


N o t e: If the person subject to extradition becomes aware of the search warrant before being arrested, the lawyer must inform them of the option to submit to the extradition proceedings in order to potentially avoid (provisional) extradition detention or to obtain a waiver of detention. This is because neither in traditional extradition proceedings nor in proceedings based on the European Arrest Warrant is it mandatory that the person sought be detained for the duration of the proceedings.

The State Attorney General’s Office (GenStA) and the Higher Regional Court (OLG) assess—without being strictly bound by the requirements of the requesting state—whether there are grounds for detention (see § 15 IRG: risk of flight or risk of tampering with evidence) exists. Pretrial detention pending extradition is almost always ordered on the grounds that there is a risk of flight. However, this justification is undermined if the person being prosecuted voluntarily turns themselves in to the police or the public prosecutor’s office before being arrested.

Don`t overestimate the potential for a dispute with INTERPOL during extradition procedure

If you are arrested anywhere in the world on the basis of an INTERPOL Red Notice and become involved in extradition proceedings, you should not overestimate the potential for a dispute with INTERPOL. This is because INTERPOL reacts extremely slowly, and it almost always takes several months before any response is received at all. And even if, after many months, INTERPOL removes a Red Notice from its system, the national arrest warrant issued by the requesting state remains in force, and this national arrest warrant has long since been converted into an extradition request in Germany. INTERPOL does not revoke arrest warrants; it merely removes them from its search engine.

You can contact the CCF (Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files) at INTERPOL. You can ask the CCF to delete a Red Notice, but nobody can guarantee the outcome, and deletion does not cancel the national arrest warrant. If you are already involved in extradition proceedings, you can put the matter with the CCF on hold for the time being; in any case, it is more important to deal with the German court handling the extradition proceedings, as this is time-sensitive.

If you are not yet involved in extradition proceedings but fear that there is a Red Notice with INTERPOL, it makes sense to contact the CCF (Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files) in order, firstly, to find out whether there is a Red Notice or any other wanted person entry and, secondly, to apply for its deletion.

7. First hearing - Local Court - Detention Order

Following his arrest, the person sought must be brought before the judge of the nearest local court without delay, no later than the following day (Sections 21, 22 IRG).

At this first hearing, the accused generally has no chance of being released; with very limited exceptions, release does not fall within the jurisdiction of the local court judge, who initially only determines whether the correct person has in fact been arrested and whether that person might consent to extradition immediately.

Furthermore, the local court judge is only required to provide the person sought with comprehensive instructions and to question them (see § 22 IRG); however, this serves merely to prepare the case for further proceedings before the Higher Regional Court (OLG).

Only if it becomes apparent during the questioning that the arrested person is not the individual named in the international arrest warrant, that the  arrest warrant has already been revoked in the meantime by the requesting state, or that its execution has been suspended, must the local court judge order the release of the person who has just been arrested (§ 21( IRG). If none of these exceptions apply, the judge at the local court issues a so-called detention order and arranges for the transfer of the person sought to the nearest pretrial detention facility (No. 40(3) RiVASt).

The local court judge informs the person sought, among other things on the possibility of simplified extradition and of waiving compliance with the principle of specialty (§ 41 IRG). Simplified extradition requires that the person sought irrevocably consent to extradition. The judge must also inform the person sought that the declaration of consent to extradition and the waiver of the principle of specialty are irrevocable (§ 41 IRG). In my experience, this often leads to misunderstandings, particularly when the person sought has an inexperienced legal representative by their side during their hearing before the local court and ultimately does not understand what they have waived.

As a general rule, the decision on provisional extradition detention and formal extradition detention is made by the locally competent Higher Regional Court (OLG) in the days following the first hearing before the locat court, by means of a written extradition detention order (§ 17(1) IRG).

However, the local court judge must immediately and by the fastest means possible notify the Office of the Attorney General (GenStA) if the person subject to extradition raises objections to extradition detention that are not manifestly unfounded, or if the local court judge himself has reservations about maintaining the detention, so that the Office of the Attorney General (GenStA) can promptly seek a decision from the Higher Regional Court (OLG) (§ 21(5) IRG). The local court sends the transcript of the hearing to the Office of the Attorney General (GenStA), which submits it to the OLG if the proceedings continue.

The arrested person`s lawyer has the opportunity at any time to submit defense briefs to the Office of the Attorney General (GenStA) and the Higher Regional Court (OLG) and should, from the outset, keep abreast of when decisions are expected so as to always be able to submit statements in a timely manner.

Please call us on +49 (0) 211 1718380 or email us at duesseldorf@ra-anwalt.de to find out how we can help you.

Our firm maintains a 24 Hour Emergency Line +49(0)172-2112373 or +49(0)172-7056055

Contact us ...